Last updated
📈 The Path to Growth: Career vs Daytrading?
Maintained by heyfinfam • 4.5 ★ (2 reviews) • 42
Got time on your hands? Should you look at reading good or Robinhood?
This View helps compare the potential financial return from dedicating your available free time to either advancing your career (seeking raises, promotions, new jobs) OR actively managing your investment portfolio (attempting to outperform market benchmarks).
It estimates the total annual gain from committing all your available weekly hours to one path versus the other. Key considerations:
- Career Growth: Salary increases often range from 10-20% for promotions or job changes. Returns on time are generally more predictable than trading, though may diminish at very high hour counts.
- Active Portfolio Management: Consistently outperforming the market ('alpha') is rare. Studies show the vast majority (>90%) of active traders lose money or quit long-term. This calculator includes a diminishing returns factor for active management – the more time you spend, the less additional alpha each hour may generate, reflecting increasing difficulty and potential over-trading. Probability of loss remains high regardless of time spent.
Use this tool to frame your decision, weighing potential gains against the high risks and low success rates of active trading. Based on your inputs, this compares the estimated annual financial benefit of focusing all your available hours on either career growth or active portfolio management.
- If Career Growth is recommended: Committing your time to career advancement likely offers a higher and/or more reliable financial return compared to the high-risk, low-probability outcome of successful active trading.
- If Portfolio Management is recommended: Your estimates suggest dedicating your time to active management might yield a higher return if your 'Base Expected Alpha' is achievable, even with diminishing returns. Exercise extreme caution and skepticism. This outcome is statistically unlikely. Re-evaluate if your expected alpha is realistic given that most active traders lose money.
Inputs
Calculations
Annual Income Gain (If All Hours on Career)
Portfolio Alpha Adjusted for Diminishing Returns
Annual Portfolio Gain from Active Management
Estimated Annual Gain from Passive Investing (Context Only)
Further Reading
- Day Trader Profitability/Success Rates (Investopedia)
- Day Trading Statistics (Unbiased.com)
- Is Day Trading Profitable? (NewTrading)
- Negotiating Promotion Salary (Fairygodboss)
- Salary Increase When Changing Jobs (ResumeWorded)
- Passive vs. Active Fund Performance (Yodelar)
- Passive vs. Active Management Differences (Investopedia)
- Choosing Passive vs. Active (Fincart)
- Average Stock Market Return (NerdWallet)
⚖️ Results & Recommendation
Est. Annual Income Increase (Focus: Career)
Est. Annual Portfolio Gain from Active Management
Portfolio Value Breakeven Point
Gain Advantage (Career vs. Portfolio)
Career or Portfolio?
Focus on Career Growth
Disclaimer: This content and any calculations provided are for informational purposes only. The views, calculations, and methodologies expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of this platform. Not financial advice. Users are solely responsible for any decisions made based on this information.