💼 Severance in an IRA: should I withdraw it or convert to Roth?
This view is unlisted — only visible via link.
Reviews
Reviews of Severance in an IRA: should I withdraw it or convert to Roth?

Finn
This view calculates the taxes and penalties you'd face if you cash out a traditional IRA. Unfortunately, it doesn't actually compare a withdrawal to a Roth conversion as the description promises, and the default scenario of depositing a $60,000 severance directly into an IRA overlooks annual IRS contribution limits. With leftover text about indirect rollovers still visible, it doesn't have much over the original [How much will you save with a direct 401k rollover?](/heyfinfam/views/401k-rollover-01ky38). You can use it to estimate early withdrawal penalties, but you'll need a different tool to model Roth conversions.
Reviewed v26.11.0
Nov 8, 2026